|
|
|
Report of the Sub-Committee on Nutrition at its Twenty-Fifth SessionII. Work in Progress: Summary of Discussion and ConclusionsC. Reports of decisions taken in Working GroupsC.7 Iron Deficiency Control -- Summary Report of the Working Group 51. This Group's report discusses technical issues, along with some encouraging reports from agencies. However, it was noted with dismay that attention paid to the problem is not commensurate with its magnitude. Control (encompassing both treatment and prevention) calls for an integrated, strategic approach. Such an approach would combine dietary interventions, fortification of appropriate foods and supplementation of the most vulnerable groups. Promoting exclusive breastfeeding and appropriate complementary feeding, improving women's reproductive health and child spacing, and controlling infectious disease (with special concern for malaria and parasitic diseases that directly precipitate iron deficiency and anaemia), are an integral part of this approach. 52. Prevention of iron deficiency throughout the lifecycle is needed, focussing on periods when iron deficiency can cause the most lasting damage, i.e., pregnancy and young childhood. This requires assuring that mothers enter pregnancy with adequate iron and folate status and also meet their added iron needs during pregnancy. Success requires information, education and communications components (IEC), along with monitoring and evaluation. Micronutrient malnutrition often appears as a cluster of deficiencies. A human rights approach was welcomed. 53. The Group agreed that:
Full Report of the Meeting of the Working Group on Iron DeficiencySunday 29 March 1998, Oslo, Norway Chairman: Nevin Scrimshaw, UNU Chair's Introduction The magnitude and significance of iron deficiency were strongly emphasized in the December, 1997 SCN Third Report on the World Nutrition Situation and through an update provided by WHO during the session. The 1997 report of the Working Group summarized the multiple serious consequences of iron deficiency and iron deficiency anemia for cognition, resistance to infection, physical performance, metabolic impairments, morbidity and mortality. The goal of micronutrient interventions is to move at-risk groups to a level of nutritional sufficiency compatible with good health. To achieve this multiple concurrent approaches that lead to sustained nutritional security are required. Also needed is a strategic framework that recognizes that several micronutrient deficiencies are often clustered in the same underprivileged population and the biological interactions among the nutrients occur. Advocacy for the control of iron deficiency should address these issues. A number of approaches must be used in a carefully planned and integrated approach to prevent effectively iron deficiency in children and women. The unfortunate misconception that effective approaches to iron deficiency are not available is due to the fact that iron deficiency cannot be effectively addressed by one or two universal actions as is the case for the control of iodine deficiency (universal iodization of salt) or vitamin A deficiency (supplementation or fortification). Under most real life situations there is no single effective intervention for the elimination of iron deficiency. An appropriate set of intervention strategies must be selected, weighed, integrated and adapted to the needs of different populations, environments and the availability of resources. The importance was stressed of expanding the focus on iron deficiency from supplementation during pregnancy only to the prevention of anemia in young children because of its impact on cognitive development and in non-pregnant women because of the need to have them enter pregnancy with adequate iron stores. The introduction stressed the feasibility of building effective programmes for the elimination of iron deficiency as a public health problem in most countries. However, they require a combination of food-based approaches including fortification, dietary change, new agricultural technologies and health-based interventions such as supplementation, disease control and reproductive health initiatives. Unless circumstances are exceptional, the single intervention and single nutrient approach to the control of nutritional anemias and micronutrient deficiencies, including iron deficiency, must be considered obsolete and should be abandoned. The combined interventions now available lend themselves to dealing simultaneously with deficiencies of iron and zinc as well as folate and other B vitamins. Where vitamin A deficiency exists, its correction can benefit iron deficiency control programmes and vice versa. Control of infectious diseases will benefit the status of most nutrients. Recent data show that iodine deficiency affects iron status, as well as thyroid function. Other health measures such as immunization and sanitation to reduce infections and the treatment of parasites also have multiple nutritional benefits. The working group agenda was structured to promote open and critical discussion aimed at helping build consensus around an integrated, sustainable strategy for overcoming iron and related nutrient deficiencies. Strategic Framework for Discussions The rapporteurs presented the integrated strategic framework shown in Figure 1 to guide all presentations and discussion. When the report was subsequently presented to the SCN, its applicability to integrated programmes for the joint prevention of vitamin A deficiency and iron deficiencies was noted.
Bruno de Benoist, Micronutrients Focal Point, WHO Geneva, presented a summary of preliminary information on iron deficiency from a new database in WHO Geneva. It was noted that current figures are often subnational, unrepresentative and sometimes from biased sources and that WHO is still working try to resolve such data related issues, Table 1 summarizes some of the WHO data: Table 1 Prevalence Estimate of Anemia (percent of populations)
It was emphasized that:
Food-Based Approaches Fernando Viteri, Coordinator of UNU's Programme for the Control of Iron Deficiency, introduced the issue of dietary practices and agricultural developments and reported on recent studies of the bioavailability of iron in foods. Dietary improvement, with emphasis on meal composition, should be part of all major anemia prevention strategies. Some "knowledge, attitude and practice" (KAP) studies are in progress that look at diet and iron deficiency in various populations, but more such studies are needed. However, there are no solid evaluations on the impact of nutrition education on the prevention of iron deficiency and iron deficiency anemia. One study has shown, not unsurprisingly, that higher meat intake markedly improves iron nutrition in late infancy. The fact that, in many parts of the world, diets containing a nutritious variety and adequate amounts of healthy foods are simply not affordable was stressed. In many societies, including some in developed countries, even where healthy diets are affordable, eating patterns and other factors unrelated to diet result in high levels of anemia, especially among young children, adolescent girls and women of child bearing age, whether or not they are pregnant. In other societies, inequitable practices in household food distribution result in nutrition problems even when the ingredients necessary for a healthy diet are available in the home. Overall, it was seen as very unfortunate that there are no current data to support the position that dietary education alone is sufficient to improve the iron status of populations. Viteri reported new plant based approaches that include selection of bean varieties that have up to five times the content of iron and zinc. Some plants have been identified that are highly effective in absorbing minerals from the soils. There are also newly developed mutants such as corn varieties that are significantly lower in phytates, and varieties of the genus Brassica that have levels of iron that open a better opportunity for sufficient dietary iron for vegetarians. The potential health and development risks vs benefits of mutant varieties were questioned mostly on the basis of their phosphate content. Viteri replied that the seeds of the low phytate mutant corn seed do not have a lower phosphate content when compared to non-mutant equivalent varieties, and that there was no evidence that the lower phytate mutant had any negative effect on health. Fortification Venkatesh Mannar, Executive Director of the Micronutrient Initiative, described activities related to food fortification as an important approach to the prevention of iron deficiency. Technologically, the addition of iron to modern flour mills is not difficult and an iron premix costs less than US$0.36/1000 kg. The most common fortificants for wheat flour are elemental iron and ferrous sulphate. A recent study in Venezuela showed a highly significant decrease in anemia rates among children two years after national introduction of iron fortified flour. Wheat consumption has increased dramatically in Asia, making this grain a more effective vehicle for fortification to bring iron and other micronutrients to populations at risk. It was universally agreed by participants that folate should be combined with the various iron compounds used to fortify cereals because of the known health benefits of this substance and the risks of brain stem defects associated with inadequate folate status. The current status of iron fortification in the developing world includes good progress in Latin America, newly developed policies in the Middle East and recent moves toward wide scale fortification of wheat flour in the new republics in Central Asia, South Africa, and Indonesia. EDTA iron is produced in large quantities for agricultural purposes, and if used widely for flour fortification would solve several problems related to stability and interactions of reactive iron with other elements in flour. More importantly, it is much better absorbed and improves the absorption of non-heme iron. Progress is being made on obtaining a "Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAS)" rating for it in the U.S. China has decided to fortify all soy sauce with EDTA iron. Vietnam is considering a similar type of fortification with EDTA iron of fish sauce. There was a concern in the U.S. that EDTA consumption in food is already high, but recent data show that this is not the case. Mannar reported that China is building a large plant for the production of EDTA iron and should have significant capacity for export. MI has made progress in the development of a "sprinkled" form of supplement/fortificant that can contain multiple micronutrients and be convenient for use with young children. There was agreement that all strategies for the prevention of iron deficiency and iron deficiency anemia should include a strong component for improving diets. Good nutrition should be about the universal availability of nutrients through the consumption of a healthy variety of foods. Supplementation Field trials and absorption studies: Viteri noted that iron supplements are well justified as part of most integrated approaches to the prevention of iron deficiency. Data show that even in developed countries a significant number of women enter pregnancy with iron deficiency. The level of hemoglobin and iron stores of a woman at the start of pregnancy is the strongest indicator of her iron status at term, regardless of supplementation during the pregnancy period. Iron deficiency prevention strategies, therefore, need to focus not only on pregnant women but also on preventing women from entering pregnancy deficient in iron. This requires a programme focus on women=s entire reproductive cycle and on iron deficiency in children. Viteri also presented a summary of the research on supplementation effectiveness and strategies for delivering iron supplements. He reported that all studies of weekly iron supplementation have been efficacious. These include three in infants in three countries (Brazil, China, Indonesia), three in preschool children in three countries (Bolivia, China, Indonesia), five in school children in four countries (Indonesia, Guatemala, Mali, Panama,), four in women 13-45 years of age in four countries (India, Indonesia, Tanzania, USA) and five studies in pregnancy in five countries (China, Indonesia, Guatemala, Malawi, Mexico). This amounts to a total of 20 studies in 10 countries (Bolivia, China, Guatemala, India, Indonesia, Malawi, Mali, Mexico, Thailand, USA). Six additional studies are in progress, including two in pregnancy, in five countries (Kazakhstan, Peru, Philippines, Uruguay, Vietnam). The results of these studies provide overwhelming evidence to make weekly iron supplements an option for iron deficiency anemia if high compliance levels can be sustained. Based on the known difficulties in achieving significant iron status improvements through large scale daily supplementation programmes, research on alternative dosage amounts and period has accelerated significantly in the past few years. The efficacy of weekly supplementation with doses lower than those received through a daily regime is an extremely important finding because of its potential for lowering supply costs. Its lesser frequency and lower side-effects should make it possible to achieve better compliance by developing effective communication support strategies and involving the community. However, its large scale feasibility and sustainability for mass use are still to be demonstrated. Ray Yip reported on the ineffectiveness, in Vietnam, of daily supplementation without any educational or motivational component. Obviously, non-compliance in taking an individual dose has greater negative effect in a weekly regime. In general, strategies including supplementation that ignore or underplay various forms of education and supervision, do not appear to be successful in reducing anemia. "Supervised" distribution through schools and work places works well. Mass communication and community channels that can educate and motivate women and mothers to comply in taking supplements and administering them to children were seen as essential. Community involvement in such programmes is a must. A weekly dose regime is more amenable than daily supplementation to promotion in the form of a weekly "event" focused on reminding individuals to take, or administer to children, weekly iron supplements. The weekly dose regime is also freer of side effects that deter compliance. Discussions led to a consensus that whether daily or weekly supplementation, the framework of an integrated iron deficiency strategy includes attention to assure that target groups are given the information and motivation for compliance. Revisits and reminders from health care providers and other community members and counseling of mothers were noted as essential. Health education for anemia control can also help reverse recent undesirable trends in some countries away from integrated prenatal care and toward a focus on building systems for dealing with obstetrical emergencies. Most existing programmes using supplementation as a major strategy for anemia prevention were seen as exhibiting an imbalance of emphasis on supplies and distribution compared to information, education and communication in support of compliance in taking the supplements and in promotion of improved dietary practices. The majority of the group agreed that the potential for adding additional micronutrients where multiple forms of micronutrient deficiency are present should be more strongly emphasized and that appropriate supplements and fortification premixes supplying some other vitamins and zinc should be encouraged. Other information and points raised in discussion of this issue included:
Rainer Gross, GTZ emphasized that:
Gary Gleason of the International Nutrition Foundation (INF) presented progress on development and implementation of the integrated strategy proposed by UNICEF for iron deficiency anemia prevention and control in the Central Asian Republics and Kazakhstan that was outlined at the 24th SCN meeting in 1997. The strategy has now formed the basis for a set of five interrelated national projects that are moving into phased implementation that began in May 1997 starting with one oblast of Kazakhstan. The initial impetus for design of this strategy was the findings of the USAID funded DHS surveys in Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan that for the first time included hemoglobin testing of national samples and revealed high rates of iron deficiency anemia in both women and children. Key Issues for Improving Iron Nutrition Ray Yip, UNICEF Indonesia, summarized key issues that affect the use and success of an integrated approach to achieving and sustaining iron deficiency anemia prevention and control. Major Issues of Programme and Intervention Focus include:
Iron Deficiency in Early Childhood
Anemia and pregnancy:
Why Multiple Micronutrients should be considered:
Essential Steps to Move the Effort of Prevention of Iron Deficiency Forward:
Reports of Key Activities during the Past Year and Upcoming Actions World Health Organization
United Nations Childrens Fund
Food and Agricultural Organization
Pan American Health Organization
International Atomic Energy Agency
United Nations University
Micronutrient Initiative
United States Agency for International Development
Canadian International Development Agency
Asian Development Bank
United States Centers for Diseases Control
General Discussion The integrated strategic framework that was presented by the rapporteurs was well accepted and used to structure the discussion. It was agreed that there had been too many programmes based mainly on only one or two elements. Monitoring of intervention processes as well as evaluation of impact was stressed. Equally essential are supervision, education and communication support not only to improve the distribution of supplements to large population groups but also to improve compliance in their consumption. The general discussion considered many of the issues that had been raised in the introductory presentations and in the reports by organizations. Views were wide-ranging. Despite some doubts, the majority stressed that for many countries cereal fortification with iron was feasible and desirable as national policy and that much greater effort should be directed toward developing multi-nutrient premixes for use in flour fortification. It was emphasized that despite its conceptual simplicity fortification of wheat flour was not a simple task and required considerable expert advocacy, technical assistance, solid planning, and follow-up monitoring and evaluation in order to assure that the product produced had consistent good quality, was acceptable to the population, could be sustained and made some impact on iron status of the population. It was also pointed out that fortification should not be seen as a "trivial" complement to other components of the strategy. It was estimated conservatively that flour fortified at typical levels would add the equivalent of 30 mg of iron every 21 days to the dietary intake of the average woman. The "piggy-backing" of additional micronutrients on this process was also seen as making good economic sense where appropriate because of the presence of additional micronutrient deficiencies. It was noted that the costs of supplementation are relatively modest. Calculated on the basis of US $0.0027 per 60mg tablet, yearly supply costs are US $98.55 per thousand individuals for programmes using daily administration of 60mg FeSO4 + folate. For weekly 60mg FeSO4 + folate they are US $14.04 per 1,000 population covered. For pregnant given 120mg FeSO4 + folate weekly they cost US $28.04 per 1,000. The linkage of a strategy to prevent iron deficiency to other related public health efforts was agreed as a key element for success. Reproductive health, immunization, the integrated management of the sick child initiative, the Baby Friendly Hospital Initiative and Breastfeeding Promotion as well as malaria control and hookworm control were among such programmes. Since hookworms contribute directly to iron deficiency anemia, incorporation of hookworm control measures as part of the anemia prevention package can help to raise the often low priority for such measures within Ministries of Health. Although several participants pointed out the lack of evidence for the effectiveness of dietary education alone in reducing iron deficiency, there was total agreement that this component should play a key role in programme strategies. While the importance of food-based and dietary change approaches was agreed upon, it was also noted that even in the USA and Argentina where meat consumption is very large the problem of iron deficiency anemia in children and women remains significant. It was pointed out that it is important to understand and convey to Governments that not only fortification but also some supplementation should be viewed as long-term strategies and not just short term interventions. This was bolstered by studies showing that over 20 percent of women in otherwise well nourished populations may be anemic during pregnancy. Technical points flagged for additional work included:
Finally, it was emphasized that despite the number of meetings on iron in the past two years there remain several contentious issues including anemia treatment guidelines that urgently need to be reviewed and updated. In response, the Chairman noted that the UNU, UNICEF and MI are planning a small meeting later this year for the specific purpose of identifying and clarifying a number of these practical issues that are blocking or inhibiting more rapid programme development. It is hoped to achieve consensus on these issues in order significantly to strengthen the advocacy tools needed to further raise the issue of iron deficiency and nutritional anemias, on national and agency agendas. The outcome of the meeting should be clear and agreed upon options and a comprehensive framework for effective and sustainable programmes for iron deficiency anemia prevention and control. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR SCN AND AGENCY ACTIONS 1. The SCN should recommend that national Governments, and international and bilateral agencies and NGOs working to design and implement programmes and projects aimed at reducing iron deficiency in young children and women use an integrated strategic framework to address this public health problem on a sustained basis. Such a comprehensive intervention should be based on a life-cycle approach and focus mainly on preventive measures. In particular, these should include a combination of:
2. The SCN should recommend that, wherever appropriate, iron deficiency prevention programmes be dynamically linked with related health programmes including breastfeeding promotion, prevention of other nutritional deficiencies, reproductive health and family planning, measures to control infections, appropriate immunizations, malaria control where needed, environmental sanitation and clean water supply, promotion of breastfeeding and baby-friendly hospitals, and HIV control efforts. 3. The SCN should recommend that in dealing with iron deficiency anemia, a life cycle approach is necessary and thatthe focus of impact evaluations and intervention planning be on:
4. WHO, UNICEF, UNU and other appropriate agencies need quickly to come to a consensus on the range of supplementation options that should be considered by programme planners as they attempt to develop effective, affordable and sustainable programmes for the prevention and control of iron deficiency and iron deficiency anemia in various countries and settings. 5. WHO urgently needs to review and update its current recommendations for the treatment of iron deficiency anemia in women and children. 6. The Micronutrient Initiative is requested to accelerate and strengthen current efforts to bring EDTA iron into a position of wider acceptance, lower costs and greater availability to countries wishing to fortify cereal flours and other foods with iron. As a corollary it should support the development of technical guidelines and manuals for the use of EDTA iron as a food fortificant. 7. UNICEF is urged to review the goals established at the World Summit for Children and ratified by the ICN on the prevention of iron deficiency in order to broaden them to include more specific targets for the reduction of anemia and iron deficiency in infants, young children and all women of child-bearing age. 8. UNICEF is encouraged to work with appropriate partners and experts to develop a stronger "human and child rights" based linkage for programmes aimed at preventing iron deficiency and iron deficiency anemia in women and children. 9. WHO, UNICEF and the UNU are encouraged in their planning of a technical consultation aimed at improving consensus on guidelines for addressing iron deficiency related issues at national and subnational levels and on advocacy materials for planning effective multifaceted national iron deficiency prevention programmes. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||