United Nations Non-Governmental Liaison Service   

12.12.2003

home     about ngls      un-ngo relations      publications      un news      staff/contacts     faq     links

                                                  Serving the UN system and NGO community since 1975       

NO 96   FEBRUARY MARCH 2003                            
  FOCUS   NGO AND OTHER NEWS   UN UPDATE
PrepCom II of the World Summit on the Information Society
Further Progress Needed in Afghan Peace Process
UNEP 22nd Session of Governing Council
IFAD Holds 25th Anniversary Session
Conference Follow-Up Working Group Meets
Commission for Social Development Holds 41st Session
Investment in Women Stressed on International Women’s Day
Publications Online

 Calendar

UN/NGO News
First Global Accountability Report Launched
World Vision/WFP School Feeding Programme
Popular Coalition Becomes International Land Coalition  

More....

 

Panel to Assess UN-Civil Society Relations
UN Estabishes Secretariat of Permanent Forum
ICC Elects Judges
Migrant Workers Convention Enters into Force     

More........

 

TOP

  PrepCom II of the World Summit on the Information Society

The second Preparatory Committee meeting (PrepCom II) of the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) met in Geneva from 17-28 February 2003 to begin elaborating a declaration of principles and programme of action to be adopted at the Summit’s first phase, to be held in Geneva from 5-12 December 2003 and hosted by the Swiss Government. The second phase is scheduled to take place in Tunis from 16-18 November 2005, hosted by the Government of Tunisia. 

The WSIS process is held against the backdrop of the profound societal changes brought about by the rapid spread of the new information and communication technologies (ICTs). It began as an initiative by the 1998 Plenipotentiary Conference of the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) and was subsequently endorsed in 2001 by UN General Assembly resolution 56/183. In the resolution, the summit process is meant to address “the whole range of relevant issues related to the information society.” ITU was identified to assume the leading managerial role for the WSIS Executive Secretariat.

Intergovernmental negotiations at PrepCom I, which was held in Geneva from 1-5 July 2002, mainly focused on procedural issues, notably accreditation and participation rules for “observers” —NGOs and other civil organizations, business entities, and international organizations (see NGLS Roundup 95). PrepCom II began the process of collating possible elements for the declaration of principles and programme of action into two working documents, mainly drawing on inputs from the series of regional meetings that took place in the interim period. Some elements were also drawn from other sources, notably an unofficial paper produced by the Chair of the PrepCom, Adama Samassékou (Mali), on the basis of an expert meeting he convened in late 2002.

The PrepCom agreed to entrust the Chair of the intergovernmental drafting group, Lyndall Shope-Mafole (South Africa), with the responsibility of revising the working documents with additional inputs from governments. In an innovative move, the PrepCom also decided that inputs from observers should be incorporated into a separate section of the revised documents, which were made available on the WSIS website (www.itu.int/wsis) on 21 March. These two documents (open for additional comments until 31 May) will serve as a basis for substantive negotiations that will begin at an intersessional meeting to take place in Paris (France) in July 2003, and carried forward at PrepCom III in Geneva from 15-26 September 2003.

A Broad Agenda?
On the basis of the embryonic intergovernmental negotiations at PrepCom I on the substance of the Summit agenda, it was very unclear how broadly Member States would be willing to venture in addressing “the whole range of relevant issues related to the information society” as called for by the General Assembly. It was clear that a set of ICT and development-related questions would be part of the agenda, such as seeking to overcome the so-called “digital divide” through infrastructure development, or promoting ICTs for health, education and other essential services. However, by the end of PrepCom II, a much broader set of issues appeared in the intergovernmental working documents, including: the role of traditional media such as broadcasting and print; the right to freedom of opinion and expression; “the right to communicate;” the right for citizens to access information, including access to “a vibrant and rich public domain;” open standards and open source software as basic elements in developing more affordable access to ICTs; the protection of privacy; Internet governance; the creation of local content; and cultural and linguistic diversity. The observers’ section of the document covers a range of additional issues, such as excessive concentration of media ownership and the energy implications of much wider ICT use.

It should be noted, however, that these working documents are at this stage only the basis for negotiations, commencing proper at the July intersessional session, with the understanding that the whole content of both texts are in brackets—meaning none of their elements can be assumed to be subject to intergovernmental consensus.

NGOs and Civil Society Get Organized
In the lead-up to PrepCom II, the Civil Society Division of WSIS Executive Secretariat undertook consultations with focal points from different sectors of civil society with the objective of proposing the establishment of a “Civil Society Bureau” that would interact with the Intergovernmental Bureau on procedural matters and act as a communication channel with various civil society constituencies worldwide. Much of the civil society discussions during the first week of PrepCom II focused on this proposal. A key concern expressed by participants was to ensure that the functions of the Civil Society Bureau would not include representations on substantive matters, which they said should be left to thematic caucuses and working groups that coordinated their collective inputs during the second week through a Civil Society Content and Themes Working Group. Much of the input of that working group is reflected in the observers’ section of the official working document released on 21 March.

In the revised terms of reference of the Civil Society Bureau, it is recognized that the daily Civil Society Plenary is “the highest decision and policy-making body of Civil Society in WSIS” and to which the Civil Society Bureau reports regularly. The Plenary agreed to set up an electronic Civil Society Plenary list for consultations online if and when needed between the PrepComs. Thus far, the Civil Society Bureau is composed of elected focal points from different civil society constituencies, grouped into 22 “families,” ranging from academia and education to media. The full list of families and terms of reference of the Bureau can be found on the WSIS Executive Secretariat Civil Society Division website.

Contact: Louise Lassonde, Civil Society Division, WSIS Executive Secretariat, Place des Nations, CH-1211 Geneva 20, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/730 6365, fax +41-22/730 6393, e-mail <info@geneva2003.org>, website (www.geneva2003.org

TOP

  Further Progress Needed in Afghan Peace Process 

The Special Representative for Afghanistan, Lakhdar Brahimi, told the Security Council on 31 January that the peace process in Afghanistan needed to progress “much further” before it could be safely said that it was irreversible. To achieve that, Afghanistan would need to count on the continuing financial and political commitment of the international community. With the challenges in Afghanistan not yet overcome, Afghans were watching developments elsewhere with some sense of fear that they would be forgotten again, Mr. Brahimi said.

Saying that the challenge in 2002 was to consolidate the fragile foundations of peace, the Special Representative highlighted three main areas on which to focus: solidifying the key institutions of the State; pursuing national reconciliation; and showing tangible results on reconstruction projects throughout the country. With respect to reconstruction, Afghans must be presented with clearly identified projects to build the economy and increase confidence in the government. Progress must also be made on building the army. Mr. Brahimi warned that too many Afghans felt excluded from the government and the political transformation now taking place, and suggested the door should be open to those who wished to participate. He stressed that leaving them out could undermine the peace process.

In spite of the relatively calm security situation, incidents continued to occur across the country as a result of inter-factional tension and sporadic terrorist activity, the Special Representative said. Drug production and trafficking in Afghanistan remained a critical concern, he stressed.

Turning to the judicial sector, he said that reforming it was one of the greatest challenges facing the Transitional Administration in the coming year. For some time to come, progress in establishing the rule of law would continue to be significantly constrained by the depleted pool of experienced lawyers and the limited capacity of the penal system, Mr. Brahimi pointed out.

In a review of positive developments in 2002, he said it was clear that Afghanistan had made “remarkable” progress on many fronts. Major political milestones had been reached on time, including the holding of the Emergency Loya Jirga and the establishment of the current Transitional Administration under President Karzai’s leadership. The government had developed a comprehensive budget through inter-ministerial planning, and had successfully launched a new currency. The Commissions called for under the Bonn peace process had all been formed, and had begun their work. Last year also saw the return of more than 1.5 million refugees and 500,000 internally displaced persons to their homes, and the return of three million children to school.

From April through early June 2003, the Constitutional Drafting Commission would conduct country-wide public consultations to discern the public’s views on key constitutional issues, he explained. Taking into account the results of the public consultations, the Commission would finalize a draft by late August. The final step would be the convening of a Constitutional Loya Jirga in October 2003 to review and adopt the Constitution.

The June 2004 elections called for by the Bonn Agreement would be an important step towards restoring accountable and legitimate government in Afghanistan, he said.

On human rights, Mr. Brahimi said the Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission had steadily been implementing its work programme with the support of the UN Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA), the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) and the UN Development Programme (UNDP). The programme covered capacity building in the fields of investigations and monitoring, human rights education, promotion of the rights of women and transitional justice. The Commission had so far received more than 600 complaints and petitions from individuals and groups. Priority areas continued to be cases of intimidation and violence against political party and civil society activists by regional local commanders. Mr. Brahimi said that ongoing investigations by UNAMA’s human rights office have confirmed an increase in the incidence of ethnic conflicts related to land disputes, and added that human rights officers have sought to engage with provincial authorities in mediating land disputes between Uzbek and Turkmen communities in the Kunduz area and helping to establish land dispute settlement mechanisms.

Speaking of the poor human rights situation in Herat, Mr. Brahimi cautioned, “It is important to note that the human rights problems occurring in Herat are happening elsewhere in Afghanistan. Human rights abuses are so endemic, after the decades of war and State collapse, that real change in the human rights situation will require systemic reform.”

Addressing relief, recovery and reconstruction, he called attention to the UN Transitional Assistance Programme for Afghanistan (TAPA), which was launched in Oslo in December 2002, including the Mine Action Programme’s new target to clear high impact areas contaminated with mines and unexploded ordnance within five years, as well as preparations for the National Census.

He also said one of the highest assistance priorities this year would be to support the communities likely to bear the impact of the 1.2 million refugees that were expected to return in 2003. Encouraging progress had been made this year in creating labour-intensive programmes and developing the National Emergency Employment Programme. The latter was anticipated to generate millions of workdays and assist in reviving local economies.

The progress made in implementing the peace process over the past year had been remarkable, but now was not the time for complacency, he stressed, stating that this year’s agenda was just as challenging as the 2002 agenda, if not more so. In order to capitalize on the progress that had been made and to meet the challenges ahead, the Special Representative said it would require the continued commitment of the Afghan people to the process and the sustained engagement of the international community.

TOP

 UNEP 22nd Session of Governing Council

A worldwide crackdown on mercury pollution, an agreement to help the environment of the Occupied Palestinian Territories and assistance for small island developing States (SIDS) to reduce their vulnerability to climate change were among the key agreements made at an international environment ministers meeting held in Nairobi from 3-7 February 2003. Some 1,000 delegates, including nearly 100 ministers from 148 countries, UN agencies, international organizations, academia, NGOs, business and industry, and youth organizations attended the 22nd Governing Council of the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the fourth Global Ministerial Environment Forum (GMEF) held at UNEP’s headquarters in Nairobi.

During the week-long session, the Governing Council agreed a number of decisions on a wide range of topics, including international environmental governance, post-conflict environmental assessment, water policy and strategy, chemicals management, sustainable production and consumption patterns, the role of civil society, and the links among environment-related conventions and between the environment and cultural diversity.

Other decisions concerned the follow-up to the World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD) held in Johannesburg (South Africa) in September 2002 and support to Africa as nations re-emphasized their commitment to Africa and the environmental part of the New Partnership for African Development (NEPAD). They also urged UNEP to work closely with governments on the continent as well as the specialized committees of the African Union, the African Development Bank and other UN organizations.

According to some observers, the European Union, with its stringent environmental standards, made attempts in the negotiations on chemicals and sustainable consumption and production to move beyond WSSD commitments. Other developed countries, such as the United States, and developing countries, including South Africa, resisted this effort.

The mercury decision (UNEP/GC.22/L.7) followed discussions on a global assessment report (see box) compiled by UNEP and experts, and which was presented to delegates. Countries agreed that “there is sufficient evidence of significant global adverse impacts from mercury and its compounds to warrant further international action to reduce the risks to human health and the environment.”

Under the action plan, UNEP has been asked to assist all countries in a wide ranging initiative to cut emissions of mercury from sources such as coal-fired power stations and incinerators. Measures may include advising countries on cleaner-coal methods, improving the efficiency of power stations and help on switching to other forms of electricity generation, including renewables such as wind and solar power. Assisting countries on reducing other sources and causes of mercury pollution, including contaminated waste sites, dental amalgams and equipment, will also be part of the plan.

Countries also backed a new effort to strengthen environment laws and their use, especially in developing countries and countries with economies in transition. The initiative, which has grown out of the Global Judges Symposium held at WSSD, aims to boost knowledge of environment laws among judges, prosecutors and other relevant individuals and groups.

An Intergovernmental Panel on Global Environmental Change (IPEC) was also set up (UNEP/GC.22/CW/L.3), inviting governments, intergovernmental organizations, scientific bodies and NGOs to submit their views to the Executive Director on issues such as gaps in knowledge in global environmental change, scientific credibility, the interaction between science and policy development, and the role of existing institutions. A report on these submissions will be prepared and submitted to the Global Ministerial Environment Forum in 2004.

Under decision UNEP/GC.22/CW/L.1, UNEP will provide SIDS with technical and financial support to strengthen their capacity to help them to achieve their sustainable development goals. UNEP will also increase funding to SIDS during the 2004-2005 biennium to prepare for next year’s summit of small island developing States in Mauritius and to implement the outcomes of that conference (see Go Between 95). The conference also urged UNEP to strengthen its role and advance its activities to reduce the vulnerability of least developed countries, small island developing States and developing countries most vulnerable to the adverse effects of climate change.

Environment ministers unanimously endorsed UNEP’s report on the environmental situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territories (see Go Between 95), and called for action to improve the environment in a decision that seeks to benefit the people on both sides of the conflict. The decision also backed a package of over 130 recommendations aimed at improving a wide range of environmental issues in the territories, including water supplies, the disposal of wastes, land degradation and the threats to wildlife and habitats.

“Our main hope for the region is that the conflict can be resolved and the suffering brought to an end. Environmental cooperation can be a tool in the peace process. Governments have asked us to act as an impartial moderator, when requested by both parties, to assist in solving urgent environmental problems with a view to achieving common goals. We are ready to do this,” said UNEP Executive Director Klaus Töpfer.

The fourth Global Civil Society Forum took place from 1-2 February in Nairobi. The meeting consisted of a regional segment focusing on the Environment Initiative of NEPAD, and a global segment on the role of civil society in implementing the outcomes of the WSSD. Their recommendations were presented to the Governing Council.

Victor Hugo, from the Center for Human Rights and Environment (Argentina), speaking on behalf of the Global Civil Society Forum, expressed concern that UNEP is “lagging behind” in its relationships with civil society. He welcomed UNEP’s strategic paper on civil society involvement, endorsed the prompt creation of a civil society advisory panel to UNEP’s Executive Director, and proposed a UNEP initiative on cultural and biological diversity in partnership with other institutions.

The eighth special session of the Governing Council/fifth Global Ministerial Environment Forum will be held in March 2004 in the Republic of Korea. The Governing Council’s 23rd regular session/sixth Global Ministerial Environment Forum will take place from 21-25 February 2005 in Nairobi.

Contact: Eric Falt, Director of UNEP’s Division of Communications and Public Information, PO Box 30552, Nairobi, Kenya, telephone +254-2/623292, fax +254-2/624489, e-mail <eric.falt@unep.org>, website (www.unep.org/GoverningBodies/GC22/). 

TOP

 IFAD Holds 25th Anniversary Session
The International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) held the 25th anniversary session of its Governing Council from 19-20 February in Rome under the theme of Achieving the Millennium Development Goals, with UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan urging increased global partnership across geographic and ideological borders to fight hunger. Mr. Annan called for a “green revolution” in Africa to enable the continent to move towards self-sufficiency in food. 

Addressing the delegates from 162 Member States, including 28 government ministers, the Secretary-General noted that IFAD’s creation was a new type of partnership—between the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) and industrialized countries, between developing and developed countries—for the shared goal of eradicating poverty and hunger. “Partnership continues to be the key for IFAD’s success,” Mr. Annan said, adding that its mission went beyond alleviating short-term food crises. “That means pursuing structural changes in rural areas to empower the rural poor and increase their resilience.”

The Secretary-General stressed that in times of famine, AIDS is depriving countries of their capacity to resist by weakening those mechanisms that enable populations to fight back—in particular the coping mechanisms provided by women. “That means we must combine food assistance and new approaches to farming with treatment and prevention of HIV/AIDS,” he stressed. “It means developing new agricultural techniques appropriate to a depleted workforce.”

Pointing out that three-quarters of the world’s poor still live in rural areas, the Secretary-General said, “We must address the fact that for them, the rapid march of globalization internationally, and liberalization domestically, currently creates more risks than opportunities.” He urged working together to help them reach the quality and standards required, and to ensure that trade policies and intellectual property rights allow poor producers a sustainable position in the new system.

Conflict and poverty reinforce each other, IFAD President Lennart Båge said on the opening day of the conference. “Poverty is the source of hopelessness and despair, which feed tensions that can lead to conflict,” he warned. “Conflict, on the other hand, is devastating for poor communities. In conditions of conflict, you cannot grow food, build businesses or otherwise take steps to improve your life.”

Former President of Mali Alpha Oumar Konaré cautioned that ignoring the plight of the world’s extreme poor would result in greater tension and conflict around the globe. “If the international community is not prepared to devote substantial amounts to helping organizations like IFAD, WFP [World Food Programme], FAO [Food and Agriculture Organization] and our countries, we will never find a way out of this predicament…and insecurity will increase for everyone in the world,” he warned.

Eveline Herfkens, the UN Secretary-General’s Executive Director for the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) Campaign, said that farm subsidies of the industrialized countries were seriously hampering prospects of eradicating poverty and hunger. The MDGs were agreed upon by 189 signatories at the Millennium Summit in 2000; topping the list was a commitment to reduce by half the number of poor and hungry in the world by the year 2015 (see NGLS Roundup 98).

“These Millennium Development Goals are doable,” said Ms. Herfkens, speaking on the first day of the Governing Council. “It is a question of the right priorities.” According to her, Western country farm subsidies are leading to over production, driving down world prices and undermining people’s livelihoods in developing countries. “It is intolerable that every cow in Europe is subsidized to the value of US$2,” she said. “The world’s 1.2 billion poor, 75% of whom live in rural areas, eke out an existence on just US$1 a day.”

Ms. Herfkens pointed out that subsidies to cotton farmers in the United States had caused the collapse of cotton prices and especially hit African producers. West African countries have lost US$200 million in foreign exchange earnings and the region’s 11 million cotton-producing households have suffered increased poverty as a result of the subsidies. She also pointed out that European Union subsidies of milk powder had destroyed the livelihoods of farmers in countries such as Tanzania.

An interactive panel discussion on Achieving the MDGs by Enabling the Rural Poor to Overcome their Poverty was held. It looked at how IFAD can more effectively enable the rural poor to overcome their poverty and how it can contribute in coming years to the achievement of the MDGs.

A series of roundtable discussions were also held, including: Indigenous Peoples and Sustainable Development; Promoting Market Access for the Rural Poor in Order to Achieve the MDGs; Transforming Rural Institutions in Order to Reach the MDGs; and Women as Agents of Change.

The roundtable discussion on indigenous people heard there are some 300 million indigenous peoples living in 70 countries throughout the world with most of them living in conditions of extreme poverty. Participants stressed the fact that indigenous peoples have considerable potential in overcoming their own poverty. Their role as guardians of the environment and as repositories of traditional knowledge and management systems was acknowledged, and speakers called for more efforts to ensure that indigenous peoples benefit from the patrimony and reap some of the rewards.

As well as more resources, indigenous peoples also need help in preserving their cultures, languages and identities, participants said, also noting that a greater say in decisions which affect their lives is crucial, if their voice is to be heard in the national and international arena.

The roundtable focusing on women found that there can be little prospect of eradicating poverty and hunger until the status of women is improved in the developing world, noting also that the advancement of women is also critical to the achievement of many of the other MDGs, including those on reducing infant and maternal mortality, achieving universal primary education and stepping up the fight against HIV/AIDS.

A fairer deal for women is crucial to the success of the first and perhaps most challenging target, that of halving the number of extremely poor people by the year 2015, the session heard. Gender inequality is a root cause of poverty, especially in the case of rural women who are among the most vulnerable and impoverished members of society. Women account for about 70% of the world’s poor.

The shift towards privatization taking place in many developing countries means new constraints for women, because the private sector is dominated by men, said Jocelyn Dow, President of the Women’s Environment and Development Organization in Guyana. So too does the growing trend for migration, as poor rural women seek jobs away from home. The result, in many cases, is the breakdown of the family, she said.

On 20 February, IFAD’s 162 member countries agreed on a replenishment of US$560 million to be invested over three years in fighting rural poverty. According to IFAD, funding for agriculture and rural development has dropped by 50% over the past 15 years—even though agriculture is the main income-earner, main employer and main engine of economic growth in most developing countries. Mr. Båge said the replenishment will enable IFAD to do more to help people overcome poverty and that this, in turn, will help poor communities become more resilient.

“The consequences of poverty—epidemic disease, migration, environmental devastation and armed conflict—do not respect national borders,” said Mr. Båge. “They affect us all—no matter where we live. Only when we have eliminated the gross violation of human dignity and human dreams that is the result of persistent poverty will we have the foundations for long-term peace, stability and sustainable development.”

Contact: Sappho Haralambous, IFAD, 107 via del Serafico, 00142 Rome, Italy, telephone +39-06/5459 2238 fax +39-06/5459 2034, e-mail <ifad@ifad.org>, website (www.ifad.org). 

TOP

 Conference Follow-Up Working Group Meets

The General Assembly Ad Hoc Working Group on the Integrated and Coordinated Implementation of and Follow-up to the Outcomes of the Major UN Conferences and Summits in the Economic and Social Fields is taking up the complicated question of how to orient the activities of the UN system, Member States, and all relevant stakeholders so that they work most effectively toward the implementation of the decisions and commitments made at these meetings throughout the last decade.

Holding its initial meetings over the past three months, the GA Ad Hoc Working Group, which was established by the General Assembly in December 2002 (see NGLS Roundup100), has been examining the role of Member States, the role of the UN system including the Bretton Woods institutions (BWIs), the role of civil society and the private sector, and the role of holding conferences in the future.

The initial discussions reveal the difficulties in understanding what is involved in shifting the intergovernmental focus away from policy making to implementation. For some delegations the most critical aspects of this centre on coordination amongst all stakeholders and defining what their respective roles should be. Suggested actions in this area include:

— improving coordination amongst the UN System, BWIs, and other institutions;
— linking the policy framework of the conferences with the operational work of the UN funds and programmes, s pecialized agencies, BWIs and the World Trade Organization; 
— defining clearly the related but distinct roles of the UN General Assembly and ECOSOC and its subsidiary bodies;
— aligning the priorities of the GA Second (economic and financial) and Third (Social, Humanitarian, Cultural) Committees around conference follow-up and implementation; and
— identifying a list of crosscutting themes to guide and structure the coordinating work of ECOSOC.

Other delegations have focused more on how to ensure that governments are actually living up to agreed commitments and obligations of conference outcomes. While acknowledging that greater coordination is necessary for effective conference follow-up, some delegations have pointed to a General Assembly resolution from 1996 (A/RES/50/227) entitled, Further measures for the restructuring and revitalization of the United Nations in the economic, social and related fields, which includes a comprehensive list of recommendations on coordination and many of the same issues that the Working Group is discussing now. They suggest that the current exercise should therefore not focus its energy on renegotiating but rather constructing a new framework on accountability, particularly in the areas of financial resources, technology transfer and capacity building.

Discussions, which have largely been of an informal nature, have not yet resulted in any conclusions but have suggested agreement in some areas and the need for further consideration in others. For example, many Member States have articulated that governments have the primary responsibility for the implementation of the outcomes of the conferences and that this principle should be based on both national ownership and international partnership.

The question of the relationship of conference follow-up to the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) has been raised, with delegations agreeing generally that policies of all countries should be consistent with efforts to achieve the internationally agreed development goals including the MDGs. However, delegations do not all agree to what extent the MDGs should play a prominent role in conference follow-up. Some believe that the MDGs provide a clear framework through which disparate follow-up activities could be pulled together. Others, however, are concerned that the conferences over the past decade included commitments and agreements that went beyond the scope of the MDGs and they are worried about losing the significance of these other areas. Concern has also been expressed over using each of the eight goals in a balanced fashion and ensuring that Goal 8—on developing a global partnership for development—features as prominently as the other seven, which are more domestic in orientation.

The Working Group is expected to make recommendations on the holding of future UN conferences and summits. Some delegations have argued that because governments, the UN system and other stakeholders are finding it difficult to cope with the already existing body of intergovernmental commitments and obligations, holding more conferences in the near future would only add to that burden. Others have pointed out that conferences and their review processes have been crucial in building political support and public awareness around issues and that they should continue to play a role even as the UN system moves into “implementation mode.” Some delegations have proposed that each issue could be assessed on a case-by-case basis and thereby not rule out the possibility of a large-scale event, but at the same time not automatically assume that a conference is the best way of making progress on an issue.

The Working Group is expected to conclude its work by June 2003, when it will issue a report of its recommendations.

Contact: Marion Barthelemy, Officer-in-Charge, Policy Coordination Section, Division for ECOSOC Support and Coordination, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, United Nations, Room DC1-1416, New York NY 10017, USA, telephone +1-212/963 4005, fax +1-212/963 3351, email <barthelemy1@un.org>, website (www.un.org/esa/coordination/ecosoc/wgga/wgga.htm).

TOP

  Commission for Social Development Holds 41st Session

National and international cooperation for social development was the theme of the 41st session of the Commission for Social Development, meeting at UN headquarters in New York from 10-21 February 2003, as governments considered five sub-themes, including: sharing of experiences and practices in social development; forging partnerships for social development; social responsibility of the private sector; impact of employment strategies on social development; and the policies and role of international financial institutions and their effect on national social development strategies.

Secretary-General’s Report
As well as the five sub-themes, the Commission also considered the Secretary-General’s report (E/CN.5/2003/5) on national and international cooperation. Unlike the concept of international economic cooperation, which the Secretary-General’s report notes has had a long history at the UN, social development has largely been seen as a national task supported by the international community mainly by means of aid, capacity building and technical cooperation. The 37 policy recommendations contained in the report underscore the complexity and breadth of national and international cooperation for social development. However, the report also emphasizes that while the primary responsibility for development rests with national governments, without international support many developing countries would find it difficult to reach their development objectives within reasonable timeframes.

Among the recommendations is the need to enhance national ownership of and responsibility for development policies and programmes. “Governments should avoid adopting approaches to development that reduce national autonomy in setting priorities for social development. South-South cooperation should play an important role in that regard, by promoting mutual learning among developing countries.” According to the report, “building the capacity of developing countries to create effective structures and formulate policies for development is a primary objective of international cooperation.”

In this context, the reports says that donors need to provide cooperation in ways that interfere less with government functions by using sector-wide approaches and by reducing aid-conditionality. Multilateral organizations should develop focused strategies and financial packages to assist countries facing catastrophic events such as war, financial crisis and natural disaster. International financial institutions should strengthen efforts to ensure that concern for improved social outcomes is incorporated into their policies and into the national policies they support. The private sector, the report emphasizes, should contribute to social development through constructive engagement, seeking business opportunities that increase participation and improve wellbeing.

“The integration of economic and social policies is a prerequisite for society’s wellbeing as a whole,” the report concludes. As the harmonization of economic growth and social policies is crucial to successful social outcomes, the report recommends considering the transfer of the social agenda items of the General Assembly’s Third Committee to the agenda of the Second Committee.

In this respect the work of the Commission was also scrutinized. Under-Secretary-General for Economic and Social Affairs Nitin Desai said that given the growing role of social development in the mandates emerging in other areas—such as the World Trade Organization’s Doha (Qatar) round of trade negotiations and the Monterrey International Conference on Financing for Development (Mexico)—he felt that the Commission’s added value was mainly as a forum for national exchange and focus on specific groups like youth and family.

Debate
“Effective cooperation is a categorical imperative for fulfilling social development goals,” said Commission Chair Iftekhar Ahmed Chowdhury (Bangladesh) at the start of the session. “Developing countries need resources, as well as the knowledge and capacity for their utilization. Such cooperation should be designed to reduce the information gap, help build capacity, promote a fair trading regime, protect the resource base, and generate employment and wellbeing of the people.”

During the general discussion of the priority theme, speakers stressed the importance of international partnerships for social development. Many delegations agreed that while governments had the primary responsibility for social development, the private sector also had an important role. The need for capacity building with regard to international development and assistance was also emphasized, as was the link between social development and economic growth, with many speakers stressing the need to simultaneously address both issues.

Speaking on behalf of the European Union (EU) and associated States, Greece said that in building partnerships for social development, the focus should be on building “vertical” links between global and national action, and “horizontal” links between governments, civil society and the private sector. Partnerships should be built around the axis of the 1995 World Summit for Social Development and the Millennium Declaration, with the 2002 Monterrey Consensus of the International Conference on Financing for Development delivering the means to achieve their goals.

While governments had the primary responsibility for social development, the EU said, the private sector also had an important role. In that regard, the EU said it promoted the concept of “corporate social responsibility,” including fair practices, decent working conditions and equal opportunities. The UN, the EU said, should continue to play an important role in encouraging corporate social responsibility at a global level. The EU also emphasized the importance of corporate transparency and accountability to all stakeholders, including employees, consumers, suppliers and community members. Accountability should focus on the “triple bottom line,” the EU said, comprised of not only economic but also social, environmental and performance indicators.

Morocco on behalf of the Group of 77 developing countries and China (G-77/China), stressed the importance of establishing innovative and mutually beneficial partnerships to reinforce national and international cooperation for social development. Governments had a fundamental leading role to play in setting up national frameworks to promote new ideas and creative partnerships, the G-77/China said, while civil society and the private sector should establish creative partnerships focused on achieving the goals of social development. Those efforts would remain insufficient, however, the G-77/China stressed, if they were not accompanied by substantial financial support allowing developing countries to achieve social development goals.

The G-77/China called on the international financial institutions to show vigilance with respect to potential financial crises that had negative social impact, especially in the developing countries, and to help those countries to develop their own capacities to prevent such crises. Assistance, the G-77/China said, should take into account the long-term development needs of the affected countries. Similarly, those institutions should give priority to granting additional official development assistance (ODA) to developing countries. For the sake of transparency, the G-77/China said, developing countries should be duly involved in the process of decision making regarding international economic issues.

In response to government concerns expressed relating to employment, International Labour Organization (ILO) representative John Langmore said that the rate of economic growth per capita that would be necessary to halve both unemployment and the number of working poor by 2010 globally would be over 2% per annum, compared with the average of 1% during the 1990s, suggesting that a major change of strategy was required. A more sophisticated balance between economic goals, he said, allowing for simultaneous reduction of unemployment and low inflation, would be an essential component for such change.

Mr. Langmore also noted that some countries were still being required to reduce expenditures during depressions in order to qualify for loans. More pragmatic fiscal policies would be appropriate in both developed and developing countries, he said. Underscoring the need for social dialogue, which he termed an “arm of macro-economic policy that was commonly neglected,” Mr. Langmore noted that education, health services, child care and care for the aged were themselves important sources of employment. The best hope for increasing income-generating work everywhere, he said, was to move towards meeting that demand.

Action Taken
The Commission concluded its session with the adoption of five draft resolutions. A G-77/China-sponsored text (E/CN.5/2003/L.6/Rev.1) on the implementation of the social objectives of the New Partnership for Africa’s Development (NEPAD) would have the Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) recommend that the Commission continue to give due prominence to the social dimensions of NEPAD in its future priority themes. The resolution also calls on the Secretary-General to ensure coordination of the work of the various UN bodies in his efforts to harmonize bilateral initiatives on Africa. In addition, the resolution stresses the vital role of the UN in assisting Member States to achieve the development objectives and targets of the Millennium Declaration and in mainstreaming them into UN development activities.

A draft resolution (E/CN.5/2003/L.5/Rev.1) by which ECOSOC would request the Commission to continue to contribute to the process established by the GA on a comprehensive and integral international convention to promote and protect the rights and dignity of persons with disabilities was also adopted. The resolution invites relevant organizations and experts to make suggestions and possible elements to be considered in proposals for a convention available to the Ad Hoc Committee.

Portugal sponsored a draft resolution on policies and programmes involving youth (E/CN.5/2003/L.4), which would have ECOSOC call on all States, UN bodies, intergovernmental organizations and NGOs concerned to make every possible effort towards the implementation of the World Programme of Action for Youth to the Year 2000 and Beyond—aiming at cross-sectoral youth policies by integrating a youth perspective into all planning and decision-making processes relevant to youth.

A draft resolution (E/CN.5/2003/L.7) on the modalities for review and appraisal of the Madrid International Plan of Action on Ageing 2002 would invite all actors at all levels to participate in the implementation of and follow-up to the Madrid Plan of Action, and to participate in a “bottom-up” approach to its review and appraisal through the sharing of ideas, data collection and best practices. The text also invites the UN system to consider mainstreaming ageing issues into the design and implementation of its work plans.

A draft resolution on preparations for the observance of the tenth anniversary of the International Year of the Family in 2004 (E/CN.5/2003/L.8) would encourage governments to make every effort possible to realize the objectives of the 10th anniversary, and to integrate a “family perspective” into the planning process.

Side Events
A one-day Civil Society Forum was held on 9 February, organized by the International Council on Social Welfare and the New York office of Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung. The Forum looked at national and international cooperation for social development as well as partnerships and the sharing of experiences and practices. It also discussed priorities for the Commission. Numerous side events also took place during the 41st session, concerning issues such as civil society approaches to policy monitoring; youth crime prevention in Africa; protection in crisis situations: challenges and issues facing children, older people, and women; and achievements in the implementation of the objectives of the International Year of the Family since 1994.

Contact: Division for Social Policy and Development, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, United Nations, DC2-1370, New York NY 10017, USA, fax +1-212/963 3062, e-mail <social@un.org>, website (www.un.org/esa/socdev).

TOP

  Investment in Women Stressed on International Women's Day
International Women’s Day was observed on 7 March 2003, with a wide range of activities taking place across the world. UN Deputy Secretary-General Louise Fréchette and high-level officials from different UN agencies linked gender equality to meeting the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), as they emphasized that social gains for women translated into improved societies.

“Study after study has shown that there is no effective development strategy in which women do not play a central role,” Ms. Fréchette said from the webcast forum held at UN headquarters in New York. “When women thrive, all of society benefits, and succeeding generations are given a better start in life.” 

A discussion moderated by Under-Secretary-General for Communications and Public Information Shashi Tharoor followed. “Women worldwide are the key to progress on all the Millennium Development Goals,” he said. “The main challenge is to find appropriate ways of combating elements in each culture that are holding women back.”

Geeta Rao Gupta, Co-Chair of the Millennium Development Project Task Force, said that the purpose of International Women’s Day was to remember promises that had been made in the context of advancing the causes of women. While women’s life expectancy in some countries had increased, she said, in other regions women comprised the least educated and most impoverished citizens. Emphasis on eliminating disparities in education was not enough, she stressed, gender equality could only be achieved through increasing women’s opportunities in the economic and political arenas, not just in the classrooms. “Development strategies must be implemented and must focus on ensuring the availability of data on women’s lives, giving greater financial and technical resources to organizations working to better the lives of women, encouraging commitment to and coordination between agencies working in the field, and spearheading a new campaign for zero tolerance of violence against women,” she said.

Nafis Sadik, Special Envoy of the UN Secretary-General for HIV/AIDS in Asia, noted that as gender advancement progressed, opposition was becoming louder. “The achievement of gender equality requires more money and resources for reproductive health, including maternal health, family planning and the HIV/AIDS pandemic,” she said. “When dealing with HIV/AIDS, one must look at the disease through the lens of tolerance, not through a lens of judgment.” Unfortunately, Dr. Sadik said, opposition to gender advancement viewed these issues “through the lens of abortion.” She underscored that reproductive health should be included as one of the indicators of progress in the achievement of the MDGs.

Emilia Fernandes, the Brazilian Secretary of State for Women’s Rights, said that the situation of extreme poverty in the world was increasingly dramatic. The international community, she said, had failed to avoid inequalities in wages and functions in the job market, and the feminization of poverty had increased worldwide. Focusing on Brazil, Ms. Fernandes noted that while there had been a gradual increase in the level of participation of Brazilian women in decision making, gender inequalities were prevalent in household employment and in the informal sector, “both of which are poorly paid and dominated by women.”
“Investment in girls’ education is one of the most effective ways of promoting economic growth and social wellbeing,” UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Sergio Vieira de Mello emphasized, noting with regret that two-thirds of all illiterate people were women. “Resources need to be made available for the education of girls,” Mr. de Mello urged. “Their education increases their ability to plan their own lives and the lives of their children. Education means they can participate more effectively in decision making at every level.” Mr. de Mello noted that attention must also be paid to the quality of education. 

A question and answer session followed, with several members of the audience stressing the importance of women’s participation in decision-making processes, as well as the central role of gender equality in the achievement of the MDGs. Concern was also expressed about States signing important international documents while doing nothing to implement them, as well as the refusal of many to deal with what was perceived as a core problem—patriarchal cultures and values.

Other UN events included an awards ceremony at the World Food Programme to honour staff and partners who have helped reduce the impact of HIV/AIDS with food relief. The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) observed the Day with two art exhibits, a forum on breast cancer and a screening of a documentary about women from various countries. The International Labour Organization (ILO) held a panel discussion of female journalists. 


Contact: UN Department for Economic and Social Affairs, Division for the Advancement of Women, 2 UN Plaza, Room DC2-1250, New York NY 10017, USA, fax +1-212/963 3463, e-mail <daw@un.org>, website (www.un.org/womenwatch/daw). 

TOP

 Publications online

CSO Newsletter Online Edition
The Civil Society Outreach (CSO) department of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) has released the first issue of its electronic information bulletin entitled the CSO Newsletter online edition. The bulletin aims to encourage the involvement of civil society actors in UNCTAD’s work, specifically in the preparatory process leading to UNCTAD XI, to be held in Brazil in June 2004.

The first edition includes articles on: diversification of exports, trade in services and environment; policies and measures to attract and increase benefits from FDI; and the inauguration of World Trade Point Federation portal, among others.

Contact: Civil Society Outreach, UNCTAD, Palais des Nations, 8-14 avenue de la Paix, 1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/917 5048, fax +41-22/917 0122, e-mail <civil.society@unctad.org>, website (www.unctad.org). 

ILO Gender Equality Tool Website
The Gender Equality Tool, a participatory website managed by the Bureau for Gender Equality based at the secretariat of the International Labour Organization (ILO), aims to promote information exchange and enhance knowledge on gender-related issues. The database-driven website is accessible in English, French and Spanish and includes gender-related links to relevant organizations and resources.

The Bureau for Gender Equality also produces three times yearly an electronic newsletter entitled Gender Equality in the World of Work that provides information on gender mainstreaming and gender equality issues. Back copies and printable versions are available online (www.ilo.org/gender). E-mail subscription requests for the newsletter can be sent to <gender@ilo.org>.

Contact: Information and Communication Specialist, Bureau for Gender Equality, ILO, 4 route des Morillons, 1211 Geneva 22, Switzerland, fax +41-22/799 6388, e-mail <gender@ilo.org>, website (www.ilo.org/gender).

Swiss Coalition of Development Organizations
The website of the Swiss Coalition of Development Organizations, including Swissaid, the Catholic Lenten Fund, Bread For All, Helvetas and Caritas, provides a wide range of information on topics related to development policy and globalization, as well as links to other websites and organizations in the realm of North/South politics and globalization. Much information is available online, including publications, press releases, conferences and meeting coverage. Print copies can be purchased online (www.swisscoalition.ch).

Contact: Monbijoustrasse 31, CH-3001 Bern, Switzerland, telephone +41-31/3909330, fax +41-31/3909331, e-mail <mail@swisscoalition.ch>.

Citizens as Partners: Information, Consultation and Public Participation in Policy Making 
Governments are in a crisis of identity, some would say legitimacy, with election turnouts low in many Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries and a widespread feeling of disenchantment among citizens with government and the democratic process. Can governments do something to change this? The publication calls for more transparency, more consultation and more participation.

The book provides comparative information on the subject and examines a wide range of country experiences, offers examples of good practice, highlights different approaches and identifies promising tools (including new information technologies). A set of ten guiding principles for engaging citizens in policy making is proposed.

Further reading: Citizens as Partners: OECD Handbook on Information, Consultation and Public Participation in Policy Making. Information on both publications is available on the OECD website (www.sourceoecd.org).

UNCTAD Dispute Settlement Course
An online course on dispute settlement in international trade, investment and intellectual property is now available on the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) website (www.unctad.org/dispsett).

The course focuses on the basic rules and jurisprudence of dispute settlement at the World Trade Organization (WTO), the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) and the arbitration rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL). It also looks at three regional approaches—those of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), the Southern Common Market (MERCOSUR) and the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN).

The course (in English only and free of charge) consists of 41 modules, 20 of which are currently available. The others will be online by 1 August.

Contact: Erik Chrispeels, Project Manager, Project on Dispute Settlement in International Trade, Investment and Intellectual Property, telephone +41-22/907 5829, e-mail <erik.chrispeels@unctad.org>, or the UNCTAD Press Office, telephone +41-22/907 5828, e-mail <press@unctad.org>, website (www.unctad.org/dispsett).

The Demographic Dividend: A New Perspective on the Economic Consequences of Population Change
Developing countries can spur economic growth by reducing high fertility rates and enacting policies to improve health, education, and job opportunities, according to a new report from Population Matters that sheds new light on the longstanding debate about the effect of population growth on economic development.

Nations that slow population growth create a window of economic opportunity afforded by reducing the proportion of dependent youths and increasing the share of productive, working-age adults. Nations that capitalize on this population change can reap a “demographic dividend” to improve their standard of living, while those that don’t may see social and economic conditions worsen. The report concludes that much of the debate has overlooked a key point: the way a nation’s population is structured across age groups is extremely important to its economic wellbeing.

More information is available online (www.rand.org/publications/ MR/MR1274/).

TOP

home  about ngls   un-ngo relations   publications  un news   staff/contacts  faq  links